October 30, 2015
Turning private tragedies into a public concern: job loss after injury or illness
Do you realize that NO professional feels responsible when a working person loses his or her job because of a health problem — neither the doctor, nor the employer, nor the person handling the claim for healthcare, disability, or workers’ compensation benefits? At most, the professionals may say “that’s a shame” assuming they are even aware it’s happened. Job loss is often invisible; the person just drops off the radar. The government insists that employers track workplace injuries and illnesses, hospitalizations and fatalities — but no-one is tracking job loss. Among the public purposes of the Americans with Disabilities Act is promoting employment of people with disabilities. The millions of workers now silently disappearing from the workforce due to newly-acquired disabilities deserve more visibility — and more help.
An estimated 2.5 million people leave the workforce each year for health reasons, most frequently due to things like low back pain and other common musculoskeletal conditions, as well as the most common mood disorders of depression and anxiety. And none of the professionals who are called on to respond when those individuals start having difficulty are being held accountable for making an active effort to help them keep their jobs. Obviously, some people really can’t continue to work (for example those who have a terminal illness or have suffered an incapacitating injury). But some of those lost jobs COULD have been averted if any of those three professionals had devoted more of their skill and discretionary effort to finding a better solution.
In my opinion, this hole in our social fabric through which people with newly-acquired disabilities are falling has been invisible until now — and is unacceptable.
To put this in perspective, as Western societies have evolved over the centuries, other kinds of private tragedies have become public concerns. Do you realize that until roughly the 19th century, no one felt responsible when a pregnant woman died in childbirth, or her newborn infant did — which was very common? “That’s a shame,” people said. It was each family’s private tragedy. Today, several professions, many hospitals, and whole departments within public health agencies in every single state focus on keeping pregnant women healthy, providing prenatal care, assuring a safe childbirth, and proper care of newborns. Maternal and infant mortality rates are now considered basic indicators of the health of a country’s entire population — and the adequacy of its public health / health care systems. In the developed countries, maternal and infant deaths are 50 to a 100 times lower than the rates in still-developing countries. Here is data from the CIA’s World Factbook.
Wouldn’t it be interesting to see a comparable table showing job loss rates for the countries? What do you think it would show? I bet the developing countries are doing less well by comparison — because their social safety nets tend to be weaker. And I doubt workers that in the US are a 100-fold better off. I’ve heard that European countries make it much harder to “throw away” unwanted workers. It is not only important for workers and their families to stay employed. Every time a worker loses his or her footing in the world of work, our society takes a DOUBLE hit: we lose an economic contributor AND at the same time we gain another person dependent on taxpayer funded benefits.
I’ve been part of a two-year effort to start thinking seriously about ways to reduce job loss due to illness and injury among U.S. workers while serving as a member of the US Department of Labor’s Stay-at-Work/Return-to-Work (SAW/RTW) Policy Collaborative. This year three of us (economists (David Stapleton, Kevin Hollenbeck, and I) were asked to develop policy papers, each on a specific aspect of the issue.
My task was to think about how to establish accountability for job loss among the professionals who have the best opportunity to influence the outcome. I felt so LUCKY to be PAID to take the time to explore this topic in depth — it was really fun to put my “thinkatorium” into high gear. Stimulating conversations with more than 30 experts in various fields and sectors of society helped shape my thinking (thank you all — their names are listed in the report). The final product is three main recommendations and a set of specific suggestions for action — how to accomplish the recommendations. I hope you will read my paper to see where this line of inquiry leads you. I bet you will be surprised — because I was.
On October 22, the U.S. Department of Labor’s Office of Disability Employment Policy (ODEP) and Mathematica’s Center for Studying Disability Policy (CSDP) hosted a policy forum to introduce the three policy papers and all of their recommendations. You can view the 90 minute video of the event here. It includes some very good questions from the audience and subsequent dialogue. All three policy papers are available on Mathematica’s website.
Please consider joining me in transforming these 2.4 million hidden and all-too-private tragedies per year into a public challenge for change.
And before you go — did you notice that the data I cited on maternal and child death rates came from the US Central Intelligence Agency’s INFORMATION WEBSITE??? Who knew? I just stumbled on it.